Curtis Granderson: Jekyll and Hyde

December 9, 2009

The tale of two seasons

The Yankees are on the verge of acquiring  Curtis Granderson, an All-Star in 2009 who may be the center fielder the Yankees have been looking for since the departure of Bernie Williams.  In Granderson, one scout said, “the Yankee’s see Derek Jeter in him.  He’s polished, professional, and can handle the spot light”  

Granderson has had a solid career thus far, with a career .270 average, 102 Hrs, 299 RBIs, and 67 stolen bases in 674 games.  It’s easy to see what the Yankees like about him.  However, it’s also easy to see why the skeptics are so critical of the 28 year-old.  


“It all depends on which Curtis Granderson shows up,” said one NL scout on Tuesday, “the ’08 Granderson or the ’09 Granderson.” 

In 2009, Granderson’s  batting average slipped from .280 to under .250. His OPS was down 78 points (to .780). His 141 strikeouts were the ninth most in the American League.  Furthermore, he had the second-lowest on-base percentage of all leadoff hitters, at .319.  His ability to hit left-handed pitching?  A woeful .183 average against south-paws, the worst in baseball.  

“And you know what really disappointed me,” said one scout, “was how he played center field, not getting balls you expect a guy like him to get to.” 

Granderson’s Zone Rating last year was 13th amongst 20 qualifying center fielders.  His range factor was 8th, and his fielding-percentage was 10th.  He also had only four outfield assists.  

As I watched the stretch-run of the AL Central race (the Mets were out of it by July) one thing was consistent:  Granderson making the top 10 bloopers on Sportscenter.  Curtis dropped and bobbled plenty of balls, and failed to throw out any runners.  What once was a strong throwing arm has declined as much as his OPS.  

What works in Granderson’s favor might be a change of scenery.   Curtis hit just .230 at home last year, with a shocking .388 slugging percentage and only 10 home runs.  Away from Comerica, he slugged 20 homers in 322 at-bats, with 25 of his 30 total coming to right field.  It seems that Yankee Stadium is perfect for Mr. Granderson.  

“He’s going to lift some fly balls,” said one of the scouts quoted earlier. “So it’s tough to say they made a mistake. At first glance, you say the Yankees gave up too much. But when you look at it, Austin Jackson is a piece the Yankees can afford to give up, because they’re just not going to play a kid every day until they turn that club over, until Derek Jeter is done and A-Rod’s on the back-end of that contract.” 

“The price was steep,” said another scout. “But I think this guy is a nice piece for their club. I have my concerns about him. But I still think he’ll fit into that lineup just fine.” 

I don’t agree that the price was steep, as Ian Kennedy and Phil Coke were expendable and Austin Jackson has yet to prove anything at the Major League level.  Nonetheless, I don’t see how Yankee fans can be overly excited about this trade, and to be fair most aren’t.  Sure Granderson is going to probably hit 25-30 home runs, but do the Yankees really need more power?  What should concern Yankee fans is his fielding, which became comical.  

If Curtis Granderson resorts back to his play of two-years ago, and turns out to be a gold-glove caliber center fielder, then this trade was brilliant.  But which Granderson is going to show up in 2010?   I guess time will tell.



  1. Why are the staying the price was steep and they gave up too much? They gave up an unproven minor league outfielder, a terrrrrrrible lefty reliever and an injury prone starter who was consistently awful when healthy…I don’t get it.

  2. dude is gonna have 40 homeruns… i heard the aaa cf was nice though… this trade was a steal… detroit was absolutely retarded for making that deal

  3. Austin Jacksonw as rated high, but he’s an unproven prospect so imo the Yanks didn’t give up much.

    However, Detroit was not retarded for this deal because they got rid of two players who bombed for them down the stretch last season in edwin jackson and curtis granderson. Omar should take notes that if players do not perform for you in crucial games then it may be time to shake things up. One of the reasons the Yanks have been successful is they have accountability. If you suck, the Yanks will just eat your contract and wont think twice about it.

    The Tigers also got the hard-throwing MaX Scherzer from the D-Backs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: